How To Sell a Lemon Car?
Written by : Ray Pierce
Last Updated: 12/03/2023

A quick overview of the topics covered in this article.

How to Sell a Lemon Car?

Lemon with wheels to look like a lemon car

Selling a lemon car, which refers to a vehicle with significant defects or issues, can be a challenging and frustrating experience. However, with the right knowledge and approach, it is possible to navigate through the process successfully. This article provides a comprehensive guide on how to sell a lemon car and seek legal action if necessary.

How to Identify a Lemon Car?

  • According to lemon laws, a vehicle is considered a lemon if it has a substantial defect that cannot be repaired after a reasonable number of attempts.
  • A substantial defect, which affects the vehicle’s use, value, or safety, qualifies under lemon laws.
  • Before pursuing legal action, lemon laws typically require the consumer to give the manufacturer or dealer a reasonable opportunity to fix the defect.
  • If the defect cannot be fixed, the consumer may be entitled to a refund or a replacement vehicle under lemon laws.
  • In addition, some lemon laws offer additional compensation for expenses incurred due to the defect, such as towing costs or rental car fees.
  • To support a lemon law claim, it is crucial to keep detailed records of any repairs or attempts to fix the defect.

Did you know that lemon laws not only apply to automobiles, but also to other consumer products like appliances and electronics?

Steps to Sell a Lemon Car:

Selling a lemon car can be a daunting task, but by following a few key steps, you can navigate the process with confidence. In this section, we’ll walk you through the necessary actions to take when selling a lemon car. From documenting all repairs and issues to consulting an attorney, determining market value, and disclosing the vehicle’s history, we’ve got you covered. We’ll also share tips on where to advertise, how to negotiate the sale price, complete paperwork, and pursue arbitration if needed. Get ready to turn your lemon into lemonade!

Document All Repairs and Issues

When selling a lemon car, it is essential to document all repairs and issues to provide potential buyers with a comprehensive understanding of the vehicle’s history. This can be achieved by:

  1. Keeping records of all repair receipts, including dates, descriptions of the issues, and the actions taken to resolve them.
  2. Maintaining a detailed log of any recurring problems or malfunctions encountered with the car.
  3. Noting any safety concerns or potential hazards experienced while driving the vehicle.
  4. Recording any communication with the manufacturer or dealership regarding repairs or warranty claims.
  5. Taking photographs or videos of the vehicle’s condition and any visible damages.

By diligently documenting all repairs and issues, you can provide evidence of the problems and demonstrate transparency to potential buyers. This can help build trust and ensure a smoother selling process.

It is also recommended to consult with an attorney experienced in lemon law cases to understand your rights and legal obligations when selling a lemon car. They can provide guidance on how to navigate the process and protect your interests.

Consult an Attorney

When it comes to the process of selling a lemon car, it’s crucial to consult with an attorney. An attorney who specializes in lemon laws can offer valuable guidance and legal expertise throughout the entire process. They will make sure that you fully understand your rights and obligations, and they can assist you in navigating any potential legal obstacles that may arise.

During the consultation, the attorney will carefully review your case and evaluate the strength of your claims. They will thoroughly examine the documentation of repairs and issues you have gathered, and provide you with a well-informed opinion on how to proceed.

The attorney can offer advice on the most suitable course of action to take, whether it involves negotiating with the manufacturer, pursuing arbitration, or filing a complaint. They will explain the potential outcomes and risks associated with each option, enabling you to make an educated decision.

By seeking guidance from an attorney, you can confidently navigate the complexities of selling a lemon car and safeguard your rights as a consumer. They will ensure that you have all the necessary information and support to make the best choices for your specific situation.

Determine Market Value

To accurately determine the market value of a lemon car, it is crucial to take various factors into consideration. These factors include the age, condition, mileage, and any pre-existing issues of the vehicle. Conducting thorough research on similar cars being sold in your local area or consulting reputable websites that offer car valuation services can be one way to establish the market value. Another option is to seek assistance from local dealerships or professional car appraisers who can provide an estimate based on the specific details of your lemon car.

Complete transparency regarding the vehicle’s history, including any past repairs or issues, is extremely important. This openness will enable potential buyers to make well-informed decisions and may influence the market value of the car. It is recommended to advertise the lemon car on appropriate platforms, targeting potential buyers actively searching for used vehicles.

It is essential to remember that determining the market value is somewhat subjective, and negotiations with potential buyers may be necessary. Remaining open to negotiation and considering offers that align with the market value and condition of your car will greatly increase the chances of a successful sale.

To effectively sell your lemon car, you should undertake steps such as researching similar vehicles, disclosing its history, and evaluating offers based on factors like age, condition, and existing issues. By following these steps, you can confidently navigate through the process of selling your lemon car.

Disclose the Vehicle’s History

When selling a lemon car, it is crucial to disclose the vehicle’s history to potential buyers. This not only guarantees transparency but also enables them to make well-informed decisions. Providing precise and accurate details about any past accidents, repairs, or damages that the car has encountered is essential. Neglecting to reveal such information can have legal consequences and tarnish your reputation as a seller.

To ensure the disclosure of the vehicle’s history, it is important to gather all pertinent documents and records that elucidate the car’s maintenance history, repair receipts, and any relevant information regarding accidents or damages. It is imperative to be thorough and include every single detail, regardless of how insignificant it may seem. Furnish the potential buyer with this comprehensive information and allow them sufficient time to review it.

By honestly disclosing the vehicle’s history, you demonstrate integrity and establish trust with potential buyers. This also aids them in accurately assessing the true value and condition of the car prior to making a purchasing decision. Remember to maintain accurate records and ensure that the information you provide is comprehensive and precise.

Selling a lemon car may present challenges, but by disclosing the vehicle’s history, you are taking a pivotal step towards facilitating a fair and transparent transaction.

Advertise in the Right Places

When looking to sell a lemon car, it is essential to strategically advertise it in the appropriate locations to attract potential buyers. Here are some effective strategies to consider:

  1. Online classifieds: Take advantage of popular websites and platforms that specifically cater to car buyers, such as Craigslist, AutoTrader, or These platforms have a broad reach and provide the opportunity to create detailed listings with photos and descriptions.
  2. Social media: Harness the power of social media platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter to effectively promote your lemon car. Share captivating photos and crucial information in car groups or on your personal profile to reach a larger audience.
  3. Local newspapers: Numerous local newspapers have designated classified sections specifically for selling vehicles. Placing an advertisement in these newspapers allows you to target potential buyers in your area.
  4. Car enthusiast forums: Engage with car enthusiasts on online forums or discussion boards that are specific to the make and model of your lemon car. These forums often have dedicated sections for selling cars, making them an ideal platform to find interested buyers.
  5. Word-of-mouth: Spread the word among your friends, family, and colleagues that you are selling your lemon car. They may know someone who is interested or can help you connect with potential buyers through their networks.

Remember, when advertising your lemon car, it is crucial to be transparent about its condition, history, and any ongoing issues. Providing accurate information will help you attract serious buyers and prevent potential legal issues in the future.

By using a combination of online platforms, local resources, and personal connections, you can effectively advertise your lemon car in the right places to reach interested buyers.

Negotiate the Sale Price

When negotiating the sale price of a lemon car, it is important to take several steps to ensure you get a fair deal. Here are the key actions to consider when negotiating the sale price:

1. Research the market: Before entering into negotiations, thoroughly research the current market value of similar lemon cars. This research will provide you with an idea of what to expect and help establish a reasonable price range.

2. Highlight the car’s issues: Throughout the negotiation process, make sure to transparently communicate all the issues and repairs the lemon car has experienced. This transparency will give potential buyers an understanding of the car’s history and may help justify a lower sale price.

3. Determine a target price: Based on the car’s condition and market value, set a target price for the lemon car. Be prepared to negotiate and consider any offers that come your way. However, it is important to know your limits and be willing to walk away if the price does not meet your expectations.

4. Be patient: Negotiations can be a time-consuming process, so maintain patience throughout. Explore multiple offers and consider different avenues for selling the lemon car to increase your chances of obtaining the best possible price.

5. Consider professional assistance: If you are not confident in your negotiation skills, it may be beneficial to enlist the help of a lemon law attorney or a professional car negotiator. These professionals can represent you and negotiate on your behalf, ensuring you receive a fair sale price.

Remember to remain firm yet flexible during negotiations and always keep your end goal in mind: to sell the lemon car at a price that you are comfortable with.

Complete All Necessary Paperwork

  1. When selling a lemon car, it is important to complete all necessary paperwork to ensure a smooth and legal transaction.
  2. Gather all relevant documents related to the vehicle, including the title, registration, and service records.
  3. Fill out a bill of sale form, which includes information about the buyer, seller, and vehicle details.
  4. Complete a release of liability form to transfer the responsibility of the car to the buyer.
  5. Provide the buyer with a valid vehicle history report to disclose any past accidents or damages.
  6. Obtain a smog certification if required by your state or local authorities.
  7. Submit any necessary paperwork to the Department of Motor Vehicles to transfer ownership.
  8. Notify your insurance company about the sale and cancel or transfer the insurance policy accordingly.

By ensuring that all necessary paperwork is completed, you protect yourself from legal issues and provide the buyer with the necessary documentation for the vehicle.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How do I sell a lemon car?

To sell a lemon car, you can follow these steps:

  • Research and find the right buyers, rather than settling for the first offer from a local junkyard.
  • Look for a company with a network of nationwide yards to get the best offer.
  • Be cautious of junkyard scams and ask to see a license before selling.
  • Understand what factors impact the offer, such as the current value of scrap metals, the amount of work needed on the car, and the number of reusable parts.
  • Consider the cost of transporting the vehicle to the junkyard and try to drive it in yourself to save money.
  • Rust, scrapes, and dings can also affect the offer.
  • Ensure you have the car title to sell it legally.
  • Take steps to increase the car’s value, such as removing personal belongings, washing and repairing seats, and draining fluids.

2. Can I sell a lemon car as a used vehicle?

Generally, it is unlikely to sell a lemon car as a used vehicle because the lemon status must be disclosed. However, if you consult a lemon lawyer first and your lemon claim does not result in compensation, you can consider selling the lemon vehicle to a professionally operated junkyard that buys lemon vehicles as junkers, as long as the lemon status is disclosed.

3. What is a lemon law buyback title?

A lemon law buyback title is given to a vehicle that was bought back or repurchased by the automaker under lemon law provisions. The vehicle is labeled as a “lemon law buyback,” and this title remains on the vehicle’s history report indefinitely. It serves as a warning to prospective buyers about the vehicle’s history of repeated problems.

4. Can I get a cash payout for a lemon car?

If you win a lemon law dispute, the automaker may offer a cash payout as part of the settlement agreement. However, the cash payout amount may include a deduction based on the vehicle’s mileage to compensate for the use you have already had from the car.

5. Where can I find the right buyers for a lemon car?

To find the right buyers for a lemon car, it is advisable to look for a company with a network of nationwide yards. These companies often offer competitive offers for lemon vehicles. One such company is Wrench-A-Part, a Texas-based junkyard with locations in Austin, Belton, Holland, and Lubbock, that is interested in buying lemon vehicles.

6. How can vehicle history reports help me sell a lemon car?

Vehicle history reports, such as those provided by CARFAX, can help you sell a lemon car by providing potential buyers with detailed information about the vehicle’s history. This information includes damage or accident records, maintenance and inspection reports, mileage manipulations, import information, thefts, change of ownership, and taxi or rental car use. Having this information available can increase transparency and trust with prospective buyers.

Share this article

Written by : Ray Pierce

Ray Pierce founded Zippy Cash for Cars in 2001 and has been in the automotive industry buying cars ever since. Starting off with 2 employees, Ray is proud to now have over 50 employees buying cars coast to coast.